Dispute Resolution

When It Goes to Court: Disputes Foreign Investors Face

Most foreign-owned companies in Turkey never see a courtroom. The ones that do usually arrive there through one of a small number of recurring dispute types — and, increasingly, only after a mandatory mediation step first.

Recent development · July 2026

Law No. 7589, in force since 31 July 2026, abolished the "indeterminate-value claim" (HMK Art. 107) used in Turkish litigation since 2011, and replaced Turkey's fixed 24% statutory legal interest rate with a floating rate tied to the Central Bank's reeschount rate. Both changes affect how new claims should be filed and how interest is calculated going forward. Read the full update →

The most common disputes

Across the matters Salik Avukatlık Bürosu sees, a handful of dispute categories recur far more often than any others for foreign-owned companies:

Mandatory mediation

Turkey has steadily expanded mandatory mediation as a precondition to litigation. It is now a required first step before filing most labor claims, most commercial claims (a broad category that includes many disputes between merchants, including payment and contract claims), and a growing list of other civil claim types. A claim filed without first attempting mediation is rejected on procedural grounds without the merits even being reached.

Mediation Law No. 6325

Mediation sessions are typically completed within a matter of weeks, are confidential, and end either in a settlement (recorded in an enforceable mediation agreement) or a certificate of non-settlement, which is then attached to the court filing. A significant share of disputes resolve at this stage rather than proceeding to litigation.

An important nuance foreign parties sometimes miss: mandatory mediation applies to the underlying commercial or labor claim itself, but the question of whether it also applies to a related arbitration or recognition/enforcement (tenfiz) proceeding concerning a foreign award has been genuinely contested in practice, with different chambers reaching different conclusions before the point settled toward treating enforcement proceedings as outside the mandatory mediation requirement. This is exactly the kind of procedural threshold question worth confirming with counsel before filing, since getting it wrong can cost months.

Commercial courts

Disputes between merchants over commercial transactions — including most contract, corporate and payment disputes involving a company — are heard by specialized commercial courts of first instance in the larger cities (including İstanbul), which develop real sector expertise given their caseload. A judgment can be appealed to a regional court of appeal and, in narrower circumstances, to the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay). Civil litigation in Turkey is generally document-heavy and judge-led rather than jury-based, with limited live witness cross-examination compared to common-law systems — a procedural culture shock for some foreign litigants used to a different style of trial.

Interim measures — an injunction to preserve assets or the status quo, or a precautionary attachment over a debtor's assets — are available and are often the most time-sensitive step in a dispute, particularly where a counterparty may move assets before a judgment is obtained.

Arbitration

Where the underlying contract contains an arbitration clause, disputes are resolved by an arbitral tribunal rather than the state courts — commonly under the Istanbul Arbitration Centre (ISTAC) rules for domestic and regional disputes, or under ICC, LCIA or similar institutional rules for larger international contracts. International arbitration seated in Turkey is governed by the International Arbitration Law No. 4686, closely modeled on the UNCITRAL Model Law, which gives foreign parties a familiar procedural framework and limited grounds for a Turkish court to set aside an award.

Arbitration is generally faster and more confidential than litigation, allows the parties to choose arbitrators with relevant sector expertise, and — critically for cross-border deals — produces an award that is easier to enforce abroad than a Turkish court judgment, because of the New York Convention (see below). It is correspondingly less suited to disputes needing urgent interim relief against third parties, or to claims (such as most labor claims) that Turkish law does not allow parties to submit to arbitration. A common — and avoidable — drafting error worth flagging here: naming an arbitrator's nationality as grounds to resist enforcement later rarely succeeds on its own; Turkish courts require concrete evidence that the arbitrator actually lacked impartiality or independence, not merely a shared nationality with one party.

Enforcing foreign judgments and awards

Because so many contracts foreign investors sign are governed by foreign law or provide for a foreign forum, what happens when a foreign judgment or award needs to be enforced against assets in Turkey — or a Turkish judgment needs to be enforced abroad — matters as much as the underlying dispute.

Foreign court judgmentForeign arbitral award
FrameworkLaw No. 5718 (Private International Law), recognition/enforcement (tanıma-tenfiz) proceedingsNew York Convention, as implemented by Turkish arbitration law
Key conditionReciprocity between Turkey and the judgment's country of origin, among other conditionsNarrow, convention-based grounds for refusal (e.g., no valid arbitration agreement, due process defects, public policy)
Depth of reviewNo review of the merits (révision au fond is prohibited) — the Turkish court checks the statutory conditions, not whether the foreign court got the law rightSame prohibition on merits review; refusal is limited to the Convention's own narrow grounds
Practical resultEnforceable, but reciprocity can be a real obstacle depending on the countryGenerally more predictable to enforce across the many New York Convention states

This is one of the clearest practical reasons foreign investors favor arbitration clauses in cross-border Turkish contracts: it avoids the reciprocity question that can complicate enforcing a foreign court judgment in Turkey (and enforcing a Turkish judgment abroad), and it channels any resistance to enforcement into a narrower, more predictable set of Convention-based defenses.

In practice

Review your dispute resolution clause before a dispute arises, not after — by the time a counterparty stops paying, it is too late to add an arbitration clause or fix a defective forum selection that will cost months in a jurisdictional fight.

Practical steps when a dispute arises

  1. Preserve the paper trail — contracts, invoices, correspondence and internal approvals are what a Turkish court or tribunal will actually decide on.
  2. Check whether mediation is mandatory for the claim type before filing anything.
  3. Consider interim measures early if there is a real risk the counterparty will dissipate assets.
  4. Coordinate with home-country counsel where the dispute touches a foreign parent's own contracts, guarantees, or insurance.
  5. Weigh settlement realistically — given mandatory mediation and typical timelines, a commercially reasonable settlement often costs less than the legal fees of seeing a contested claim through appeal.
Landmark Case Law

How Turkish courts approach recognition and enforcement

Three decisions mark out the real edges of Turkey's enforcement-friendly stance toward foreign judgments and arbitral awards — where the door is wide open, and where it genuinely is not.

Yargıtay İçtihadı Birleştirme Büyük Genel KuruluEsas — · Karar 2012 unifying decision2012
A foreign court's use of different substantive law is not, by itself, grounds to refuse enforcement

Resolving conflicting chamber practice, the Grand General Assembly for the Unification of Case Law held that a Turkish court reviewing a request to enforce a foreign judgment may not refuse enforcement merely because the foreign court applied law different from Turkish law, or because that foreign law diverges from a mandatory Turkish rule. Refusal on public-policy grounds is reserved for the narrower case where the actual legal consequence of enforcing the judgment would itself violate Turkish public policy.

This is the foundational rule that keeps Turkey a genuinely enforcement-friendly jurisdiction for foreign judgments — a Turkish court will not re-litigate the foreign court's choice of law or substantive reasoning; it checks only the statutory conditions and the outcome's compatibility with public policy.
Yargıtay Hukuk Genel KuruluEsas 2022/660 · Karar 2023/106608.11.2023
An arbitral award that conflicts with a final Turkish criminal judgment on the same facts can offend public policy

Considering a request to recognize and enforce a foreign arbitral award, the General Assembly of Civil Chambers examined whether the award's conflict with an already-final Turkish criminal court decision on the same underlying facts could amount to a violation of Turkish public policy. It held that such a conflict between a final domestic judgment and the award sought to be enforced is indeed capable of constituting a public-policy violation, since simultaneously enforcing both would undermine the coherence and unity of the legal system.

Shows one of the genuinely live public-policy exceptions to enforcement in Turkey — worth checking, before pursuing enforcement of a foreign award, whether any Turkish criminal proceeding touched the same facts.
Yargıtay 11. Hukuk DairesiEsas 2022/3126 · Karar 2023/67292023
An enforcement judgment must specifically identify the foreign judgment it enforces

Reviewing an appeal in a recognition/enforcement action concerning a French court judgment, the court held that a Turkish enforcement judgment must expressly and specifically identify the foreign court decision being enforced within its operative part — a generic reference is not sufficient — and it corrected the lower court's disposition of an interest claim that was not covered by the foreign judgment's own wording.

A useful procedural reminder for foreign judgment-creditors: enforcement in Turkey is a formal, technical proceeding, and small drafting gaps in the enforcement pleading or judgment can create real problems at the execution stage.

Case summaries above are Salik Avukatlik Burosu's own English paraphrase of the published holding, prepared for general orientation. They are not certified translations and should not be quoted as the court's original wording; always verify against the full Turkish-language decision (Esas/Karar numbers as cited) before relying on it in a filing.

Continue reading
WhatsApp